Real life isn’t fair. It makes no sense. It has no neat, comfortable story arc. It’s not like books, or movies, or TV shows, where the girl ends up with the transparently wrong guy and the two go off to live happily ever after despite their blatant incompatibility.
1. Tom from 500 Days Of Summer
A fan recently tweeted that they still hadn’t “forgiven Zooey Deschanel for what she did to Joseph Gordon-Levitt in (500) Days of Summer.” On the surface, this is a perfectly understandable sentiment; Tom and Summer are nearly perfect for each other in every way, and when the latter breaks the heart of the former, it’s difficult not to see her as a villain.
Joseph Gordon-Levitt was quick to point out the phoniness of his character Tom. A further character study reveals how Tom projects his own emotions and desires on a partner who was always upfront about her intentions. He’s the “nice guy” who turns mean when he is rejected, who is ready to lose a genuine friend because of a wounded ego.
A person’s desire for another, no matter how intense, is no reason to date them. Tom never deserved Summer in the first place.
2. Jonathan Byers from Stranger Things
Nancy doesn’t deserve Steve Harrington, but as insufferable as she herself is, she also doesn’t deserve Jonathan. Did our collective consciousness just expunge memories of him taking photos of Nancy and Steve from behind a row of bushes in S1?
Jonathan is also careless and pretentious. The one night he’s asked to stay home to make sure Will gets home safe from Mike’s house, Jonathan picks up a shift at his job. The one thing Sheriff Hopper asks him not to do—go to his sh-tty dad’s house to look for Will—and Jonathan goes tromping off to scumbag Lonnie’s.
Jonathan is creepy and angsty and maybe the worst character on the show.
3. Archie Andrews from Archie Comic Books
What do Betty and Veronica see in Archie? It’s utterly unfathomable. Dude is dumb, broke, and clumsy. His only draw is that he’s adventurous and dads hate him. Betty can be forgiven, simply because despite her glossy hair she is never given the opportunity to meet any other dudes, but Veronica has no excuse. She’s always meeting new guys and somehow still ending up with Archie.
4. Nate from The Devil Wears Prada
Adrian Grenier’s striking baby blues aside, the fact that Andy ends up with him despite his utter lack of support for her career is unconscionable. Nate wasn’t just unsupportive — he was openly, vehemently hateful of Andy’s job (as were her friends, which is another matter entirely.)
NOT TO MENTION that Andy needed to eat sh*t at her hellhole workplace for all of about one year. Rather than accepting her temporary hustle, her boyfriend (and BAD friends, who openly dunked on her as she was giving them expensive free sh*t) added to her stressful existence by getting pissy over her finally figuring out mascara and jeans that fit.
5. Mr. Big from Sex And The City
Oh, Carrie’s a “bad person” and she and Big “deserve each other?” I don’t want to hear it. Carrie may indeed be morally questionable, but she’s the protagonist of the show and she is perfectly flawed for reasons I won’t get into because A) I love her and B) Our focus here is Big.
Where do I begin? Big jerks our sartorially sublime Carrie around for years, using his commitment-phobia as an excuse—only to marry a 25-year-old he’d known for several months—only to cheat on that 25-year-old with Carrie, who he, throughout several seasons, continues to emotionally abuse and sabotage to no end.
Big established consistent patterns of behavior which perpetually made Carrie feel unwanted, confused, and stupid. He never stopped gaslighting her when she was upset, he chickened out on their wedding day, and then bought her a penthouse with a room-sized closet (though without consulting her) and all was forgiven.
Big’s a loser. Don’t @ me.
Even SATC author Candace Bushnell doesn’t think Carrie should’ve married Big!